THE STORY ON THE SURFACE: HOW CORROSION + WEAR DEBRIS ANALYSIS ARE USED IN ENGINEERING FORENSIC INVESTIGATION

分享这篇文章

2022年9月20日

设备, 组件, and machinery failures can lead to significant costs, including business interruption and equipment replacement. 是制造有问题吗?? 操作正确吗? 是否维修不足? 失败是否可以被预测或避免? The answers to these kinds of questions have significant implications for equipment providers, 业主/经营者和保险公司.

Surface degradation by corrosion and wear is one of the most common reasons for equipment failure. While both can be easily identified from the appearance of machine 组件s, the challenge to the forensic engineer is to determine how and why these failures occur.

腐蚀机理的确定

When a susceptible alloy is exposed to the right environmental circumstances, chemical degradation can occur causing metal corrosion. 例如, 低碳钢是一种常见的工程材料, but it will corrode when exposed to water and oxygen. Premature failure caused by corrosion in steel is often due to the breakdown of corrosion prevention measures.

虽然一般的腐蚀可以缓慢发生, some corrosion mechanisms create localised aggressive conditions that accelerate through-wall corrosion, causing leaks and holes in a matter of weeks or months. A through-wall metallographic section cut from the failed 组件 can help visualise the corrosion mechanism (e.g.(裂纹或点蚀).

Chemical analysis of the alloy can also help identify its susceptible corrosion mechanisms. A metallurgical investigation will combine results from the chemical analysis with information from the maintenance records and water analysis. 来自腐蚀发生地点的证据(e.g., localised at joints or near welds or where sludge accumulates) and how widespread it is throughout a system can help confirm the mechanism and possible causes.

调查穿

Wear is the other common surface degradation failure mode. It is sometimes seen in conjunction with corrosion and affected by both the properties of the metal and environmental conditions. Wear is a concern because worn parts lose thickness, and thinned areas can burst. Additionally, moving parts can loosen and vibrate or seize up from friction heating. Although moving parts are protected from wear by appropriate lubrication, wear debris can accumulate in the lubrication oil and exacerbate the problem when the oil is re-circulated.

The forensic materials engineer can try to match sludge and solid particles found in the sump oil to wear particles still embedded in a wear surface. A high magnification examination using a scanning electron microscope can help determine particle size and shape and identify the composition of the debris. The route of investigation will depend on if the wear was caused by hard contaminant particles, loose corrosion oxides or contact fretting debris from the surface.

防止腐蚀和磨损故障

Wear and corrosion can occur at a low level over a long time without causing equipment breakdown. But as they develop, corrosion products and wear debris can create problems elsewhere in machinery. If these issues can be detected and acted upon at an early stage, it’s possible to prevent a major and sudden failure. 先发制人的维护, 常规水、油取样, and condition monitoring are key to preventing breakdown.

One of the best ways to protect against corrosion is by implementing preventive measures early in the design of steel equipment and its operation. Corrosion protection typically involves the use of water chemistry treatments and barrier coatings that prevent exposure to corrosive environmental conditions. Protective measures may include adding chemical inhibitors to water storage tanks, 锅炉, 管道工程, 或管道,以及涂漆的表面, 塑料, 或混凝土.

当设备发生故障时, the story on the surface isn’t the full story the forensic engineer needs to tell. Looking closely at surface damage and appearance can often give key evidence for building the investigation.